Friday, February 10, 2012

Rumpelstiltskin

I've been re-reading fairy tales and exploring their philosophical potential. So many questions, especially about ethics, are raised by these stories! I just read a version of the Brothers Grimm story Rumpelstiltskin, as retold and illustrated by Paul Zelinsky. The story can be read, of course, as a morality tale about the greed of Rumpelstiltskin and his willingness to take advantage of the desperation of the miller's daughter, who must spin straw into gold or the king will have her killed.

But the story is more complex than that. It raises many ethical, as well as social and political issues. For example, the absolute power of the king. Is his demand that the miller's daughter spin straw into gold, or die, any worse than Rumpelstiltskin's insistence that she keep her promise to give him her first-born child? And once the miller's daughter (who is never given a name) manages (with the help of Rumpelstiltskin) this feat, the king marries her - again, the miller's daughter clearly has no choice about this either. Who is the real villain in the story - Rumpelstiltskin or the king?

Rumpelstiltskin asks the miller's daughter to promise him her necklace, her ring, and then (when she has no material things left) her first child - are the first two requests morally permissible? Should Rumpelstiltskin help her without asking for anything in return? Is it just the final request that is over the moral line? Should the miller's daughter have made this promise? Why isn't she obligated to keep it?

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Admiring the time аnd effoгt you ρut into уour ωebsite аnd
in depth infοrmаtion yоu preѕent.
It's nice to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't the ѕame
outdаted rehashed mаterial. Eхcellent read!
I've saved your site and I'm аԁding your RSS feеԁs tο my
Gοοgle aсcοunt.
my webpage :: promise ring meaning yahoo

Anonymous said...

I never would have thought about that story in that way! I remember reading it as a child and not thinking much of it. I really like your ideas and thoughts about the story.

paullamb said...

What does R want with a human child? He could make all the gold he wanted. He could come and go -- through locked doors -- as he pleased. He seems self sufficient. So why a child? to eat? to give to the devil? to make an apprentice? to corrupt?